Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Sales Credentialing, Just Another Brick in the Wall.

"We don't need no education, we don't need no thought control, no dark sarcasm in the classroom, teachers leave them kids alone, Hey Joint Commission, leave them kids alone."

In 2009, TSB wrote an article regarding hospitals charging salespeople for credentialing in order to gain access to the operating room. Yet, there has been a recent uproar within the industry over sales rep credentialing, meaning, salespeople must be trained and certified in understanding operating room and HIPAA protocol. This includes standards in how to behave in the O.R., being inoculated for bloodborne pathogens, respecting patient privacy, understanding aseptic technique, in addition to being knowledgeable with regards to the instruments and implants that the surgeon is using. Interestingly, there seems to be the illusion in the industry that sales people in general provide education, service and collaboration on all levels. It may be argued that the people representing the spine cartel are more apt to be educated and trained on standards when comparing them to some of the independent distributors that work on a daily basis in the operating room.

Many years ago, the salesperson played an integral role interacting with the surgeon, especially, when it came to developing new ideas into functional products or emerging technologies. Usually, the salesperson was the conduit performing due diligence before an engineering team was brought in. As the industry became saturated with commodity products, the entire strategic objective of early growth stage companies was to generate quick revenue at whatever expense there was associated with a new distributor. So who is to blame for all these ridiculous mandates? The government? The facility? The Joint Commission? The AORN? The early growth stage companies that have acted irresponsibly, placing no value on training and focusing only on revenue (TSB is excluding companies with so called emerging technologies)? Somewhere along the way we have lost all sense and sensibility. If the company you represent is required to have product liability insurance, and you are trained by the company, why should a rep be required to acquire their own insurance? Because some lawyer said so?

Some surgeons have argued that they have a sense of security when a company representative is available in the O.R..... Yet, TSB must ask the question, why would anyone want a surgeon operating on them if they did not know how to use the tools of their trade? Would Slash have been the lead guitarist for Guns N' Roses if he wasn't a virtuoso? Maybe the reason sales people need training, and surgeons need a pacifier, is because no one takes the time to get to know the nuances of a system. Could it be that many believe that a screw is a screw, and, a plate is a plate? Regardless, if there are over 500 pedicle screws, each system has its own footprint. Would you get into a 777 and take a transpacific flight if the pilot was not capable of navigating the plane without a flight instructor?

Since when did we make selling and servicing so complex? If you have common sense, you can be a valuable asset, if you don't, there's no hope. Selling is an art. Do your due diligence. Understand hospital protocol, and get to know all the key players. If you have no business in the operating room, don't be hanging around, especially when the day is starting and patients are being prepped in the pre-op area. If it is mandatory to sign in, sign in. Be respectful of the rules until you are given an invitation to the party. Your role is not only to show up for the case and make money, your job is to educate the staff on your instruments and implants. The smarter they are, the less they will depend on you, providing you with the time to make new sales calls. Don't overlook the people in central services because they are just as curious as others in understanding your instruments and implants. A little bit of attention can go a long way, especially if you are bouncing sets around from one account to another. If you are in the operating room, get to know everyone and identify the role they play during the procedure. This includes understanding the flow of the procedure and the surgeon's tendencies. The surgeon is the conductor and you are a piece to the orchestra. Lastly, the most important part of your job is to get to know all the people that make key financial decisions that could potentially effect your business or opportunities within that account. If you are going to consider yourself a businessman, then start acting like one, it just may save your a**. TSB wants to know what our readers think?

All in all it's just another brick in the wall..............


Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Conflict of Interest or Conflict of Virtue, You Decide

In October of 2006, the Stanford University School of Medicine implemented a program called SIIP. The acronym stood for Stanford Industry Interactions Policy. This policy governs interactions largely in the clinical and educational arenas with pharma, biotech, and medical device companies. The provisions in this policy address gifts from these industries, access of sales and marketing reps on campus, and industry support of education.

Stanford was among the first institutions to embrace such a policy. Considering the scrutiny that academic institutions and physicians are under, it's a wonder that more institutions are not promulgating the importance of this type of policy, or are they? The concern that Stanford has is that all interactions between physicians and industry must be ethical, cannot create conflicts of interest that could result in compromising patient safety, data integrity, the integrity of the educational and training program, and the reputation of faculty members at the institution. Individual physicians must consciously and actively divorce clinical care decisions from any perceived or actual benefits expected from a company. Stanford believes that it is unacceptable for patient care decisions to be influenced by the possibility of personal financial gain. It comes down to the old adage, "give a surgeon a hammer, everything becomes a nail." More on that later.

The concerns for Stanford include:

Gifts and compensation (Buying dinner, fee for attending a dinner presentation, etc)
Financial support for educational and other activities (Reps paying for educational programs that involve use of company products, i.e. AO Courses as an example)
Full disclosure of relationships with industry (Consultancies, Stock Options, Royalties, Honorarium's, etc.)
Access to the facility by sales and marketing representative
Providing scholarship or any other educational funding to residents

The Dean's concerns are legitimate in that a faculty member's relationship, whether it be a full-time or adjunct professor, could tarnish the University's image. Immediately, the Jeff Wang/UCLA, Zdeblick/Wisconsin and Polly/Minnesota scenario come to mind. Philip Pizzo's concern is the deteriorating image of the surgeon in the eyes of the public let alone the potential affect it can have in patient care. But we're not here to rehash old news. The purpose of the post is to ask our readers their opinion on the interaction between physician and company. Does a conflict of interest exist? Can a physician's judgement be influenced by their financial ties to a corporation and the success of a product? Have surgeons behavior, mostly influenced by commercial remuneration, distorted the fine line between outcomes and clinical marketing? Should there be two sets of guidelines, one for private practice, and one for academia? Or should there be stricter rules on how a surgeon can market his skills? In the larger picture, medicine has become no different than other areas of business, where everyone has a spokesperson for a brand. The real question is, if they weren't getting paid, or did not have a financial stake in a product, or a company, would they really care? Would they really use some of these products?

Maybe, Dr. Pizzo is on to something, or, maybe he is just missing out on an opportunity to maximize Stanford's ability to generate capital by commercializing the department at the medical school? It's an interesting time within the industry. Wall Street and it's analysts' have lowered the bar for the industry as a whole, yet, forecasted that the spine cartel should achieve their financial objectives by adjusting revenue and foreign currency in hope that the industry is still appealing to lure future investors, and, also to drive up the value of their own investments in these companies.

So in the spirit of debate, are you hearing other major academic institutions across the U.S. addressing their concerns about the commercial relationships between their faculty members and the industry? Or, is this an isolated situation?

The sacred Hindu scripture known as "the Gita" once said, "the fruits of action, are emphatically not the point of action." TSB wants to know want our readers think?



Want to Sell Something, Just Use the Words Best in Class

Recently, there has been an onslaught of press releases ranging from new executives being hired to companies achieving PMA milestones, to launching "new me too" products (isn't that an oxymoron), to surgeons promoting clinical results. None of this news has been truly earth shattering, nor is it going to create a major shift in spine care, nor, is this going to change some of the challenges that these early-growth stage companies face. What TSB finds interesting is the common buzz words that all these press releases contain, "best in class."

Many years ago, as more and more graduate school business executives started to infiltrate our industry, it seems the use of the description "best in class" became more the norm than the exception. It's almost like using the word "love" endlessly. It loses its meaning. So we thought that we would do a bit of investigative work to identify just what does it mean to be "best in class." When utilized does this mean that the product that someone is describing exhibits the highest current performance level in the industry? Maybe, but usually its your word against mine unless you have the revenue to prove it. What happens if there are only three or four products? Would that truly constitute using the word "best in class." Would four products even qualify as a class? What happens if someone is attempting to use these words to set a standard or benchmark, and that individual is not an authority? Would that be deception or marketing?

You have to love when someone hires a new VP of Sales, and that person is quoted as saying, "I look forward to working with the sales management team to build a best-in class sales organization as we grow our market penetration in minimally invasive surgery." Huh? Wasn't the sales team that you inherited best in class? Or, is the company calling a timeout and looking towards free agency to rebuild the organization? Is this the NBA? LeBron is available for the right price. Or, when launching a new product someone is quoted as saying, "the company's mission is only to provide best in class products." Does that mean that it hasn't been launching best in class products? Does anyone have anything interesting to say anymore? How canned can some of these comments be? Is there any creativity or artistry to our speech?

In closing, our research shows that the term "best-in-class" is given to the dog who has been judged the best specimen of its particular class at a confirmation show probably like the Westminster Dog Show. So TSB must ask the question, is it the dog, or is it best-in-class? We probably won't know until this years Spine Technology Awards ceremony in Orlando, until then keep doing your homework because you never know when someone will call you the best-in class.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

2010 Preservation of Motion in the Spine

If my memory serves me correctly, April 7th -10th will mark the 6th Anniversary of the Preservation of Motion in the Spine Meeting. When it originally started it was called Preservation of Motion in the Lumbar Spine. My how the worm has turned. Duck Key is a great resort in the Florida Keys that will afford everyone the opportunity to escape reality and spend some time polishing up on their surgical and fishing skills. This meeting has definitely evolved from a boutique meeting to a recognizable academic and surgical skills lab. In addition, the program has added some new surgeons to infuse (is that a commercial plug) some life into the program. Yet, TSB always loves coming to this meeting. The industry gets to experience the wonderful advancements that have been made in motion preservation, along with a first hand look at some of the faux pas' that have been made. Unfortunately, after reviewing the Agenda, the audience will not be treated to Brazilian Samba music as the background to Shakira dancing up and down a stairwell after reconstructive surgery for a failed disc, nor will we have to hear one of the presenters tell the audience that David Paul is a genius (I thought Einstein was a genius). But there is hope. Maybe one of the presenters will bring back the 2001 Space Odyssey music for his presentation on total disc replacement. So fellow readers, pack up your Tommy Bahamawear along with your sandals and catch a flight down to Miami International and don't forget to fill out your disclosure form.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Spine Blogger Sunday Editorial

The week ending March 28th will become known as "TW3," or That Was The Week That Was. No fellow readers, it's not the old 1962 British satirical television comedy hosted by David Frost. It's a political comedy called America. How can anyone in their right mind not revel in lampooning the American government, considering, there has been a systemic failure not only by the Democrats, but also the Republicans? Somewhere along the way, OUR SO CALLED LEADERS HAVE FAILED US. In many respects the United States is beginning to disintegrate like the Roman Empire. The transformation is complex, yet, it will not take over three hundred years. This could be the end of capitalism and free markets as we have come to know them. The parallels are precedented. Over expansion, budget deficits, the need to raise taxes unless you want your children to bear the onus of subsidizing a war and having to speak Chinese, the fleecing of America by Wall Street, and the cost of healthcare reform. We are on the brink of self-immolation. Hypocrisy, deception, greed, childish name calling, bigotry, finger pointing, death threats, homophobia, xenophobia and a fundamental breakdown of a major religion. Could I find anymore nouns to define where this once great republic lies? Have we become a nation that lacks civility?

In 2009, the History Channel broadcast a documentary entitled, "JFK, 3 Shots that Changed America." In the past three years, a real life documentary has been unfolding. It will be called, "The 3 Shots that killed America." The 3 shots that TSB is referring to are, America declaring war in the Middle East (the Bush Administration), the death spiral and fraudulent behavior of Wall Street (the Bush and Clinton Administration), and Healthcare Reform (the Obama Administration). In order to perform an autopsy, one has to inspect and dissect the victim to determine the cause, and unless people are willing to do this, the future is bleak, for everyone. Today we scream fiscal irresponsibility, yet the government failed us a long time ago, and we have no one else to blame except ourselves. We continue to vote septuagenarian's and octogenarian's into office at a time when these individuals lack the mental faculties and stamina to make prudent decisions. Politicians continue to anesthetize the American public for votes while catering to special interest dollars. The time has come to legislate and enact term limits if this behavior does not change.

The U.S. is a melting pot of diverse ethnic and cultural groups that have succeeded by working hard. No one is a pedigree American. Regardless of class, everyone wants to build a better life for themselves. Opportunity remedies failure. Unfortunately, America has lost the passion to endure, everyone wants instance gratification and entitlements, regardless whether you are rich or poor. Today, the pundits criticize this country's disease for debt, yet, when previous administrations (the liberals and conservatives) were making irresponsible decisions our attitude was "let the good times roll," never thinking about the consequences.

America was built on a middle class foundation, yet, today we have become a two-class system. We have people with diminishing wealth, and then we have the super rich. No need to worry about a foreign entity bringing the United States down to its knees, we are doing an exceptional job at it ourselves. Healthcare will be running a $4 trillion dollar deficit by 2012 and whether we like it or not everyone is an accomplice, unfortunately what we have learned about ourselves is that we do not accept accountability. So in the end, one has to wonder whether our behavior, expectations, and lack of respect in our industry is nothing more than a microcosm of the bigger picture. You know what the Yogi Berra always said; "When you come to a fork in the road, take it."

Friday, March 26, 2010

Is This an Epic Battle To Mimic the Disc?

Hydrogels have been used in breast implantation, dressings for burns and soft-tissue, topical drug delivery and in contact lenses. The effects of polyvinyl alcohol and (PVA) and polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP) have been studied for many years indicative of this materials versatility and ability to mimic a degree of flexibility similar to natural tissue. Scientists have been studying the effect of these co-polymers for many years, especially its potential in the spine. Some of the original studies focused on the replacement of the nucleus pulposus (NP) in the intervertebral bodies of the lumbar spine. These studies analyzed how dehydration affected the mechanical behavior of rehydration gels demonstrating the feasibility of nucleus replacement.

Lumbar discectomy has been proven to be an effective therapy for decompression of patients with herniated disc. So the question was asked, can the nucleus pulposus be regenerated, or as TSB would say remodeled? By identifying the viscoelastic properties of the nucleus pulposus the objective was to create a scaffold capable of integration without mechanical compromise. Many scientists believe that the swelling properties of blending PVA and PVP might allow spine surgeons to replace the NP endoscopically vis-a-vis a posterior approach.

Over the past ten years, companies have raised a tremendous amount of capital, and have also burned through an incredible amount. Some of it for research, some of it for marketing and of course some of it for its own personal use. Yet, the question, must be asked, is there a viable market of this material in spine? Some of the companies that surfaced believed if they could prove this materials efficacy, a windfall would occur. But somewhere along the beaten path it seems that the market for this material, as originally intended, is not as large in spine as it may be in other segments of medicine. So the question must be asked of our readers, is there hope for this material? And, how large of a market exists? And, do some of these companies stand the chance to execute and capitalize on their strategic objectives? Or, are their expectations greater than the reality that awaits them? TSB wants to know what our readers think?

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Show Me the Money!!!!

Based on a recent survey by NASS, 24% of spine surgeons responded that if mandated reductions in Medicare reimbursements occur, they will no longer participate in the program. Additionally, more than one-third of those respondents would opt out of Medicare for two years, and privately contract with Medicare patients. So what does that mean? Does this mean the end of spinal care for Medicare eligible patients? In all likelihood, no. What it means is that on the surface there are 76% of spine surgeons that will either provide services or are undecided as to how they should react until there is more clarity as to what the government's plan is.

Dr. Baker was quoted as saying that "these findings are indicative of the fears resonating among physicians nationwide." TSB could hear the conversation;

Spine surgeons have just told Dr. Baker that they are not going to participate in Medicare

Dr. Baker: That's great!

Spine Surgeons: Are you listenin'?

Dr. Baker: Yes!

Spine Surgeons: That's what we're gonna do!

Dr. Baker: What can I do for you?

Spine Surgeons: It's very personal. Hell, it's our motto. Are you ready Ray?

Dr. Baker: I'm ready.

Spine Surgeons: We want to make sure you're ready Ray. Here it is: Show me the money. Oh-ho-ho. SHOW! ME! THE! MONEY! A-ha-ha Ray, doesn't it make you feel good to hear us say that! Say it with us one time Ray.

Being a surgeon in today's healthcare environment must be stressful. First there is an assault by the DOJ on their abilities to act as consultants, then, there is a contingent that are complaining that the reps are making too much money, of course the CEO's are truly underpaid, then, they want to own distributorships because by doing so they will drive down the cost of healthcare, and now in all likelihood the potential exists that they will be paid less for providing medical care for medicare patients. Maybe its time to stop worrying about everyone else and just focus on the task at hand. So what's the alternative? Some speculate that there will be an early exodus by some very talented surgeons because of what transpired today. If that's the case, TSB must ask the proverbial question; What are your going to do? Become a hedge fund manger? The government is putting in regulations on shorting. Go to work for Goldman Sachs? Maybe you can make millions packaging and selling sub-prime mortgages? Nope! Gold is the next thing. Open a laundromat? Become an artist? Become a salesrep? I mean snap out of it! Surgeons have one of the greatest and most noble professions that a person can have while at the same time earning a respectable living. And if you're not happy being a surgeon, then you were never intended to be one. So in the spirit of debate, maybe, just maybe, its time to hang up the spurs and ride off into the sunset, or move to Paris.

You know what TSB says; "I was a free man in Paris, I was unfettered and alive, there was nobody calling me up for favors and no ones future to decide. You know I'd go back there tomorrow but the work I've taken on stoking the star maker machinery behind the popular song."